Homeopathy is based on the idea that
large doses of a substance cause a symptom, while very small doses of that
same substance will cure it. Homeopathy was developed by an 18th century
German doctor, Samuel Hahnemann, who founded a system based on the ancient
concept of "like cures like." Substances that cause a certain symptom in
a person are given to the person to relieve those symptoms.
The "Law of Proving" is the method used to test substances for their
healing effect. Dr. Hahnemann and his assistants conducted many provings,
taking in plant, mineral, animal, and chemical material. They carefully
wrote down the symptoms they felt with each substance. Later, when patients
had those symptoms, they were treated with very dilute doses of that substance.
This approach became the first Law of Homeopathy: the Law of Similars,
or "like cures like."
Over time, volumes of information developed from Dr. Hahnemann's years
of "provings." These volumes are called the Homeopathic Pharmacopoeia,
and they are still used as the source of homeopathic remedies. When a patient
describes his symptoms, the symptoms are compared with this large collection
of documented symptoms until a match is found. The patient is then treated
with a highly diluted version of that substance. A person complaining
of intense, throbbing headaches, for example, might be treated with a very
diluted dose of belladonna (a poisonous herb used to make some medicines),
because a tiny bite of that plant causes throbbing headaches.
Substances diluted in water or alcohol
Homeopathic remedies are made from substances diluted thousands of
times in water or alcohol. Between each dilution, the liquid is shaken
vigorously. For example, a one-to-one-hundred dilution means that one drop
of a plant extract is placed in 99 drops of water or alcohol. After lengthy
shaking, one drop of the new solution is mixed with another 99 drops of
water. This mixture is shaken vigorously, and then one drop is taken from
it and added to another 99 drops of liquid, and so on. This process is
repeated as many as 30, 50, or more times.
The end result can be a solution more dilute than one molecule of salt
placed in an ocean. A molecule is the smallest possible amount of any substance.
Most homeopathic remedies contain less than one molecule of the original
plant or chemical extract.
Today, homeopathic remedies are used most often to treat problems such
as arthritis, asthma, colds, flu, and allergies. These are some of the
most common problems for which people seek medical advice. But, some supporters
believe that homeopathic
remedies can cure many illnesses. Responsible practitioners do not
use homeopathic remedies to treat diabetes, cancer, heart disease, or other
major illnesses. Nor do they use it to treat surgical emergencies or serious
infections or injuries.
How does it work?
Some people believe that homeopathic medicine works by stimulating
the body's own natural defenses. Dr. Hahnemann believed homeopathic remedies
would replace the illness with a similar but weaker illness the body's
"vital force" could more easily overcome.
However, the use of highly diluted substances has not been shown scientifically
to work. If there is less than one molecule of a substance present, it
means that no substance remains. How then, can homeopathic remedies have
any impact on symptoms or
disease? In what way is it more than water?
The reason most commonly offered today by homeopathic proponents is
the remedy's water has a "memory" of the original substance. What is this
memory? Homeopaths say it is electromagnetic waves of the active ingredient
it once contained. They say that vigorous shakings between each dilution
make this memory possible.
Another explanation, heard less often, is that all of the shaking and
dilution activity releases the essence, or healing life force, of the original
substance. Many advocates of homeopathy indicate they do not know how it
works, and that later research will unlock that mystery. Homeopathic supporters
have not been able to offer an explanation that scientists can reproduce
or accept. How its remedies could work remains a perplexing problem for
homeopathic proponents and is a major source of scientific skepticism.
Clinical homeopathic research has produced varying results. Some studies
indicate it is effective in the treatment of allergies, infant diarrhea,
and other problems; other studies do not. Researchers in Britain recently
looked at the results from the most well-designed research projects about
homeopathy. After careful study, they decided that there was little reason
to believe that homeopathic remedies work.
Will homeopathy help?
Most scientists say homeopathic remedies are basically water and can
act only as placebos. A placebo is a "sugar pill" which appears to reduce
symptoms by means of mental suggestion. However, homeopathic remedies involve
using products that are safe and have no side effects. If only through
the power of the mind, they can be used to reduce the symptoms of self-limiting
illnesses (aches and pains that will go away on their own in a week or
so). Thus, homeopathic remedies help some people get through these problems
with fewer symptoms and may shorten the length of these illnesses.
Many avid supporters swear by homeopathic remedies for allergies, colds
and flu, and other minor but annoying ailments. Homeopathic remedies have
not been shown to have any impact on serious illness. In fact, using homeopathic
remedies may delay diagnosis and effective treatment of serious illness
when time is of the essence. Homeopathy's only medical danger lies in postponing
recognized, proven treatment for major diseases or serious problems that
are best diagnosed and treated as early as possible.
ACS News Center stories are provided as a source of cancer-related
news and are not intended to be used as
press releases.
|